Isoshi Kai Karate
  • Hōmupēji
  • Rekishi
  • Shashin
  • Yōgo-shū
  • Ōkami Sōkutsu

Kata, is it right or wrong?

6/1/2016

16 Comments

 
At some point we’ve all seen kata performed some place or another. Either in your dojo, at a tournament or perhaps in a movie or cartoon; chances are you’ve seen it. I’m sure we’re all also guilty of being over critical when watching a kata performed in whatever venue we witness it in. But there are times when seeing it done that we watch the performance and think or say out loud, “what the heck is he/she doing? That’s totally wrong!” But are we actually wrong in our own preconceived notions of how a particular kata should be performed or demonstrated? Do we fully understand the context from which the practitioner is pulling the techniques before us?
As a You Tube junkie I have seen just how over critical the vast majority of viewers can be to the videos posted by practitioners of various disciplines. There are scores of armchair black belts spewing insults and recommendations to the participants of the posted videos. Everything from, “you’re doing it wrong” to “that looks like crap” to “that bunkai doesn’t make sense” has been posted to a whole host of video comments thereon.
So lets examine kata from the viewpoint of karate. Kata or Form is a collection of techniques chained together into a pattern for the practice of karate. There is no distinguishing the various schools and styles of karate. As in with Kendo and Judo of years past, these various schools and styles are known by the names of the owners of the respective dojo.  In all budo, not just karate, the interpretations of the art by those who are training differ according to the interpretations of their instructors. Moreover, it goes without saying that variations in expression are characteristic of each individual. So, in general no two karateka will have the same interpretation of any given sequence within a stated kata. This does not mean that one is right or wrong. Merely that the perspective of each practitioner is different.
With regard to karate (including Isoshikai) if they were to be classified, they would fall broadly into one of two categories: Shorin-ryu or the Shorei-ryu. Shorei emphasizes the development of physical strength and muscular power. In contrast, the Shorin is very light and focuses on speed and dexterity, with rapid movements to the front and back. Both of these styles will develop the mind and the body. It’s important to stress here that there is no one great, grand, glorious, end all-be all style. No one style is better than another. It is the individual practitioner of the style that will make it good or bad. Any claims to the contrary are arrogance, ignorance or preconceived notion.
With that out of the way, we can examine the bunkai.  分解 (Bunkai) Literally means analysis or disassembly and is a term used in Japanese martial arts for analyzing kata and extracting fighting techniques from the kata. The extracted techniques are called 応用変化技 (Oyou henka waza), which means applied variations of technique. The key word in the translation there is variations. This implies that there is no one-way of doing things. One mans gedan barai is another mans low block and another’s hammer fist and yet another’s throw. It’s all about the individual perspective and probably more importantly the context in which the technique is applied.
So let’s imagine that we’re watching a kata demonstration. The practitioner is moving through the series of techniques and it just looks “wrong” to you for one reason or another. What makes it appear incorrect? Perhaps the karateka moves through the first four steps of Heian Nidan and the sequence appears to be completely short or rushed. Maybe it seems as though the techniques look inappropriate to the application to which you yourself are familiar. To be fair, that’s not for you or I to judge. This is why context is important to bear in mind while the karateka moves through the motions. (S)he is performing the set in the context that they were taught. The first four techniques may be demonstrated as a trapping and throwing technique instead of the strikes that most karateka are familiar with. Of course it’s also entirely possible that the student is not yet familiar enough with the kata to be performing it in this venue. This opens a whole other can of worms. It’s been my observation that all too often instructors will teach kata to their students too quickly in order to move on to the next in the curriculum before the student has fully understood the techniques within the kata in order to collect a testing fee every three months. Therefore the standards of excellence are diluted in order to pay the bills at the dojo. This results in students with a very vague understanding of a great number of kata instead of the student having a full understanding of only a few kata. It’s quality over quantity.
One area in particular that seems to miss the mark of what kata is supposed to be is in the media. This is to no fault of their own. Over the past decade there was a sharp increase in Extreme Martial Arts (XMA), which thankfully seems to have died off a bit. In their kata (if we can even call it that) demonstrations consist of spectacular aerial flips and twists are showcased with a lot of yelling, spinning and flashy kicks while clad in some interesting albeit eccentric uniforms. Regardless of how impressive the acrobatics anytime I see these demonstrations the only thought that occurs to me is “this is wrong”. Its reminiscent of gymnastics and cheerleading but with weapons and martial arts uniforms. Of course it’s entertaining to see. I just can’t wrap my head around how this is supposed to be applied to any context of the combat arts.  And the point therein is that it’s not supposed to be. It is purely for aesthetics and to demonstrate the athletic prowess of the contestants.
Still I suppose it’s my own ego or maybe even arrogance that forces me into a state of frustration when I see kata performed as a side show circus event or even the kata being performed by karateka whom clearly have no real working knowledge of the sequence of techniques or their applications. While my students have heard my self and my partner say too many times to count; it doesn’t have to be pretty. It only has to be effective. However, when it comes to kata there is a rather blurred line with that respect. There is an unwritten rule that pretty much says that the kata should be at least a little esthetically pleasing. Regardless, it’s not my place to pass judgment nor is it anyone else’s for that matter. Weather the kata is performed right or wrong through my perception is irrelevant. The point here is to be ever mindful that no two schools will have the same standards of excellence and all techniques are subject to individual elucidation. As a spectator we can all have a lesson in humility and patience if we can just keep our own ego in check and remember that there may be something going on therein that we’re not privy to.
16 Comments
Power Bank Terbaik link
9/29/2016 01:47:11 pm

I think this is all you are staggeringly extraordinary in making this blogh could be extremely fascinating, I really is trusting still visit this blogt.

Reply
best dissertations link
1/6/2017 10:07:08 pm

I remembered one of my favorite movies before which is Karate Kid. I really want to learn karate that time. It will help us girls for self defense. After I watched the movie, I have searched karate videos and I imitated the moves. Thank you for sharing information about karate. I hope that you can post more often.

Reply
http://www.topqualitysessays.org/customwritings-com-review/ link
2/12/2017 05:33:21 pm

When I was young, I always watch movies with Karate or Taekwondo or anything about martial arts. I got inspired to learn the skill from the movie Karate Kids. I really like to feel belong and be one but my parents never get me finance to learn such skill. Up until now, I didn’t get to learn that stuff but that didn’t stop me. I would just like to see my kids had the dream I dreamt. I’ve been saving for my kids to let them learn even the basic of it so they can defend themselves anytime. They like watching karate movies too and I can sense that they’re interested in learning the skill.

reviews on essay writing services link
1/10/2018 12:10:21 pm

I appreciate your blog post regarding the art of Kata. i must say, not just by this particular discipline which is somehow related to Karate, everyone should respect all the performances that they are going to watch. Primarily for those performers or artists, in different particular field, in the art of Kata or not, we should pay attention, give them some respect on how they practice a particular craft. For some reasons, there are also some people who are not knowledgeable about what performance they are doing. In that sense, we should also give them respect, not just a legit artist or performer but as a human being. We could give them some advice or make them realize to practice more. At the end of the day, all the performances such as the Kata, is purely a passion and valued craft of each performer, never assumed that they are just entertaining you for the sake of your happiness.

0123movies link
5/10/2018 11:03:53 pm

Really a great addition. I have read this marvelous post. Thanks for sharing information about it. I really like that. Thanks so lot for your convene.

------------
https://0123movies.io/movie/deadpool-2/

best research papers link
6/1/2017 04:21:09 pm

Wrong is a word that has a negative implication but if we are going to use it in another context, it is a very powerful and positive word. One may always choose the wrong decisions. It is a strong action to know you are wrong and yet continue doing whatever it is that you are doing. It gives a sense of hope that one day your reasons or lack of any will be understood. The truth is no one can really decide which is right or wrong.

Reply
the best essay writing website link
1/10/2018 03:35:07 pm

Honestly, I was not familiar with Kata and all the words you've been saying kept me alienated. But your article made me realized that I need to know it even more if I want to try to be fit. Aside from the proper food intake and various exercises we can do, I think Kata and Karate are two good options we need to explore if we are in search of new adventure to enter. I believe its going to be fun. All it takes is a good decision!

pomade adalah link
9/29/2016 02:03:03 pm

In handling your website is extremely incredible and you could do Teru always and this is a decent technique for the advancement of your web journal.

Reply
www.australianwritings.com review link
10/18/2016 04:47:28 am

Nice post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful information. Thank you and best of luck.

Reply
Jason Sigler link
11/16/2016 04:49:29 am

I just want to take a moment to thank everyone for their kind words and support. Isoshikai is a very small organization, with only three instructors in the United States. I do apologize for the tardiness in following up to your comments as I have been unavailable for some time now. Thankfully things are changing and I will be more available to answer inquiries and write more articles on all things Karate. If you have any suggestions for article topics in the future, please post them to the Isoshikai Karate Face Book page as I am on that site more often than I am the Isoshikai Website.

Best Wishes,

Jason Sigler

Reply
Digital Agency Indonesia link
6/12/2017 10:09:42 am

What a complete explanation. Thank you very much for that.

Reply
Funny Birthday Quotes link
11/1/2017 09:20:07 pm

Reply
SOL DU Exam results 2018 link
3/20/2018 04:19:52 am

Reply
Engineered flooring link
6/12/2018 07:46:49 pm

Flooring installers Vancouver are one of the best places to get your flooring and have the same installers for installation of your floor coverings. With great deals on laminate flooring and engineered hardwoods. With new lines of vinyl plank flooring as well

Reply
Kyphoplasty link
7/31/2018 04:31:19 am

This is a very useful post, thank you! I agree that innovations are the most important thing for most businesses, because with today’s fast changing world we need to stay on top of the changes, if we want to survive.

Reply
300-101 Exam Dumps Questions link
3/28/2019 12:30:29 am

This is a great inspiring .I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. I am looking to reading your next post.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Honshū & Hokkaidō

    The two species of wolf native to Japan until their extinction in the early
    18th Century and the names of our two authors. 

    Archives

    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013

    Categories

    All
    First Strike
    Funakoshi Sensei
    Isoshi Kai
    Karate
    Karateka
    Rank Belt

    RSS Feed

Site powered by Weebly. Managed by Bluehost